Everything about this sweater is perfect. The weight, the length, the overall fit -- perfect. A great addition to the closet for spring weather.

Tough call to pick between the sweaters. Loved all three of them. Each can be worn with many different bottoms. I purchased the XS blue and white. Beautiful sweater. Definitely can be worn over a shirt. The sweater is a boxy fit. Cozy and comfy.

Perfect Spring/Summer Sweater! A Classic

I wanted to love this. The quality of the sweater itself is high, however, the buttons go all the way up to the armpits on the sides, and I wasn't prepared for the amount of puckering the fabric did between each button, particularly at the natural waistline, even though the sweater was loose like on the models. The gaps produced are very noticeable and distracting unless I have my arms held closely to the sides to cover the buttons and seams as pictured by the models. I need more satisfaction from this item for the price. For reference, I am 5'7" and 135 lbs., and usually wear a S, and the S fit as pictured. Sadly, I'll be returning this.

Great classic stripe in cotton - thank you Tuckernuck, I LOVE cotton sweaters. So comfortable. Fun button detail On side and longer in back which I love. Runs true to size but it has a relaxed casual fit. I like things a little loose (not super fitted) and I ordered my regular size medium. I think it’s perfect.

I can't take this sweater off. I kid you not. It's sooo perfect. Comfortable, and not too hot. I love the side buttons- I wear them open for a more swingy look. I have the blue with white stripes and I'm seriously considering getting the yellow and white too because it's just that good. Fits true to size, I'm a 4 and have a small.

I am 5’3” and 111 lbs and I got this in size XXS and it’s perfect - still has shape and flattering but has that comfy oversized look. Can dress with jeans or slacks. The side buttons are unique and stand out. Weight of it is perfect for transition seasons spring/fall or a cool summer beach night ... love the melange color on brunette!

This sweater is the perfect weight -- great for any season. High quality, flattering fit and versatile colors make this a new favorite.

This was my first time ordering from this company, and I was surprisingly pleased! The quality of weaving is very good, and they’ve paid a lot of nice attention to details like the side buttons. I’m glad to have found a well-made cotton sweater — I like wearing cotton sweaters like this in the spring while it’s still chilly. I would give it five stars, except for the fact it runs big and stretches a bit. I recommend going a size down unless you like a baggy look.

This is perfect for spring/fall weather. It is a nice, heavy weight cotton. It is good with or without a shirt under it.

Beautiful and happy with 100% cotton, superior quality. Fit true to size. Need in solid colors too!

I debated splurging on this sweater for months, but I'm glad I took the plunge and purchased the starboard blue color. It's the perfect light cotton knit for a New England summer (and maybe every other season too). The colors are a pleasant alternative to the traditional blue and white stripe. I am 5'8 with a 38C and usually go between M/L in this brand. I purchased the L here and will enjoy the slightly oversized fit it offers. Sizing down to M could work if one wanted a more tailored look.